Sales Director
.jpg)
When it comes to selecting a phone system for your UK business, one of the most fundamental decisions isn't about which vendor to choose—it's about which deployment model makes sense for your organisation. Should you opt for a cloud-based solution hosted by a provider, invest in on-premise hardware you own and maintain, or pursue a hybrid approach combining elements of both? This decision affects not just upfront costs but your long-term flexibility, security posture, and ability to support remote work.
Understanding the fundamentals in our comprehensive guide, The Complete Guide to Modern Office Phone System Features: Everything You Need to Know in 2025, provides important context for the specific comparison below.
The distinction between these deployment models has become increasingly important as phone system technology has evolved. A decade ago, on-premise systems dominated because cloud technology wasn't mature enough for mission-critical communications. Today, that landscape has reversed. Cloud solutions now offer reliability, features, and security comparable to or exceeding on-premise systems, while eliminating the complexity and expense of hardware maintenance. Yet on-premise systems still make sense for certain organisations with specific requirements. This article explores all three approaches in detail so you can make an informed decision.
A cloud-based phone system, also called VoIP (Voice over Internet Protocol) or hosted phone service, runs entirely on servers managed by the provider. Your business doesn't buy, install, or maintain any phone system hardware. Instead, you connect to the provider's infrastructure via your internet connection.
When an employee needs to make a call, they use a physical desk phone connected to the network, a software application on their computer (called a softphone), or a mobile app on their smartphone. All these devices connect to the provider's cloud infrastructure, which handles call routing, feature execution, and integration with other systems.
Your team member at their desk presses a button or clicks an on-screen phone interface to call a customer. The call routes through the internet to the provider's cloud infrastructure, then to the customer's phone. Because everything is software-based, features like call recording, call transfer, or voicemail-to-email happen automatically without anyone having to press special codes or buttons.
The key characteristic of cloud systems is their software-defined nature. Features are controlled by code running on the provider's servers, not by proprietary hardware sitting in your server room. This means features can be updated instantly. If the provider releases a new capability, every customer gets it automatically. If a security vulnerability is discovered, it can be patched immediately across all customers.
An on-premise phone system (often called a Private Branch Exchange or PBX) is hardware that your business owns, installs in your office or data centre, and maintains. Common on-premise systems include Asterisk, 3CX, Cisco Call Manager, or Avaya systems.
When calls arrive at your business, they come through traditional phone lines (PSTN lines) or increasingly through SIP trunks (internet-based phone lines) connected to your on-premise hardware. The hardware handles all call routing, feature execution, and integration with other systems.
Your business buys the hardware (typically costing £5,000-£50,000+ depending on system size and features), installs it in your office, configures it to match your business requirements, and then maintains it ongoing. When you need new features or want to change call flows, your IT team (or a contracted technician) modifies the system configuration.
The key characteristic of on-premise systems is local control. All system logic runs on hardware in your building that you own completely. You're not dependent on an external provider for availability, and you have complete control over configuration. However, this control comes with responsibility—you're responsible for hardware maintenance, software updates, disaster recovery, and ensuring the system remains available.
A hybrid phone system combines elements of cloud and on-premise deployments. Typically, a business runs some phone system functionality on-premise (often using 3CX or a similar platform) while routing calls through the internet via the cloud provider's trunk services. Alternatively, some businesses might run core functionality in the cloud but maintain on-premise hardware for specific purposes like call recording or compliance.
Hybrid systems represent a compromise approach. They attempt to capture the benefits of both models while minimising drawbacks. However, they also add complexity that often isn't justified by the benefits.
Understanding the total cost of ownership for each deployment model requires looking beyond just monthly fees to include upfront investment, ongoing maintenance, scaling costs, and hidden expenses.
Upfront Investment: Minimal. You might spend £500-£2,000 on physical desk phones (optional—software clients on existing computers/phones work fine), plus a small amount for configuration and setup. Many cloud providers charge little to nothing for initial setup.
Monthly Costs: Typically £15-£40 per user per month, depending on features included. A 50-person organisation might spend £750-£2,000 monthly. This cost is entirely predictable and scales linearly with headcount.
Scaling Costs: Adding users is simple and inexpensive. Adding one new employee costs the same per-person fee. Removing users when they leave means that cost simply disappears—there's no hardware to reallocate or depreciate.
Maintenance Costs: Zero. The provider handles all system maintenance, updates, and reliability. You're never responsible for hardware repairs or software patches.
Internet Upgrade Costs: You'll need adequate internet bandwidth for VoIP. If your current internet is barely adequate, you might need to upgrade. VoIP typically requires about 100 kbps per concurrent call, so bandwidth requirements are modest. An upgrade from basic broadband to business-grade connectivity might cost £50-£100 monthly, but is often necessary anyway for business operations.
Total 5-Year Cost for 50-person organisation: Approximately £45,000-£120,000 depending on features, plus internet upgrades of £3,000-£6,000.
Upfront Investment: Substantial. A capable PBX system for a 50-person organisation costs £15,000-£50,000, depending on hardware specifications and feature requirements. This is a significant capital expenditure that must be budgeted and often requires board approval.
Monthly Costs: Low, typically £100-£300 for maintenance contracts and support. However, these are essential—without support, if the system fails, you have no one to fix it.
Scaling Costs: Adding users beyond the system's initial capacity typically requires additional hardware investment. If your business grows to 100 users but you sized your system for 50, you'll need to upgrade hardware. However, if you correctly anticipated growth, scaling can be inexpensive—just adding licenses.
Maintenance Costs: Significant and unpredictable. You're responsible for maintaining the hardware, keeping software updated, and replacing failed components. A failed hard drive might cost £500-£2,000 to replace, depending on how quickly it's needed. Software licenses for add-on features can add £1,000-£5,000 annually.
Disaster Recovery: You're responsible for ensuring business continuity if your system fails. This might mean purchasing redundant hardware, implementing backup systems, and maintaining geographic redundancy. These costs can easily exceed £10,000-£20,000.
Internet Connectivity: While on-premise systems can use traditional phone lines, modern implementations typically use SIP trunks (internet-based phone lines). A 50-person organisation might need 20-30 concurrent SIP trunk lines, costing £50-£100 per line monthly—£1,000-£3,000+ monthly just for phone line costs.
Total 5-Year Cost for 50-person organisation: Initial hardware investment of £15,000-£50,000 plus maintenance/support of £500-£1,500 monthly (£30,000-£90,000 over 5 years) plus SIP trunk costs of £1,000-£3,000 monthly (£60,000-£180,000 over 5 years). Total: approximately £105,000-£320,000, often significantly higher when redundancy and disaster recovery are included.
For a typical 50-person organisation, cloud systems cost roughly 40-60% less over 5 years compared to on-premise systems. The gap widens if you need redundancy or disaster recovery. However, there are scenarios where on-premise makes financial sense—specifically, organisations with many concurrent users or static headcount that will remain stable for many years.
Provider Responsibility: Cloud providers are responsible for the physical security of data centres, hardware maintenance, network security, and applying security patches. They typically maintain comprehensive security certifications (ISO 27001, SOC 2) and conduct regular security audits.
Your Responsibility: You're responsible for user authentication (ensuring strong passwords or multi-factor authentication), access control (who can access what data), and secure configuration of your specific instance.
Compliance Advantages: Most modern cloud providers are designed to meet compliance requirements, including GDPR, HIPAA, and PCI-DSS. They provide documentation and audit trails to prove compliance. Updates to meet new compliance requirements can be deployed globally within days.
Potential Concerns: Your data is stored on the provider's servers, potentially shared infrastructure with other customers (though in isolated, encrypted environments). Your business depends on the provider's security posture—if they're breached, your data could be affected.
Data Location: Most major cloud providers let you specify where your data is stored (UK, EU, US). This is important for GDPR compliance, which often requires data to remain within the UK/EU.
Provider Responsibility: The hardware vendor provides the system, but places security responsibility on you. You're responsible for applying security patches, maintaining physical security, and managing access.
Your Responsibility: Complete responsibility. You must maintain current security patches, manage firewalls and network security, back up critical data, and implement access controls.
Compliance Advantages: Complete control over your data and where it's stored. No data stored externally. Your compliance depends entirely on your implementation.
Potential Concerns: Security is entirely your responsibility. If you don't apply security patches promptly, you're vulnerable. Managing security properly requires skilled IT staff or expensive external consultants. Small organisations often lack the expertise to maintain adequate security.
Data Location: Completely under your control. All data stays on your hardware.
GDPR (UK/EU): Requires protection of personal data and gives data subjects rights to access, correct, and delete their data. Cloud providers often handle GDPR compliance more completely than organisations managing on-premise systems internally.
HIPAA (Healthcare, primarily US): Requires strict protection of health information. Both cloud and on-premise systems can comply, but HIPAA compliance is complex and expensive regardless of deployment model.
PCI-DSS (Payment card data): Requires protection if you process payment card information during calls. Compliance requires detailed security controls regardless of deployment model.
For most organisations, cloud providers offer better security in practice because they employ dedicated security staff, maintain updated defences, and deploy patches immediately. However, on-premise systems can be equally secure if managed by competent IT professionals.
User Scalability: Adding users is instantaneous and linear. Adding 10 new employees means 10 new monthly subscriptions—no system reconfiguration needed.
Feature Scalability: All features available to one user are available to all users. You can't run out of capacity for specific features—they're software-based and scale infinitely.
Geographic Scalability: Remote users, multiple office locations, or globally distributed teams are trivial to support. All employees access the same system regardless of location.
Flexibility: Downsizing is equally simple. Removing users is as easy as cancelling subscriptions. If your business contracts, costs contract immediately.
Upgrade Complexity: System upgrades happen automatically and transparently. You never need to plan downtime for system updates.
User Scalability: Scaling requires planning. If your system is sized for 50 users and you grow to 100, you must purchase additional hardware, install it, integrate it into your existing system, and migrate the configuration.
Feature Scalability: Some features might be capacity-limited. If your system has 1,000 simultaneous call capacity and you hit that limit, upgrading requires hardware investment.
Geographic Scalability: Supporting remote locations or distributed teams requires either deploying additional hardware at each location or a complex networking configuration. It's more complicated and expensive than with cloud systems.
Flexibility: Downsizing is problematic. If your business contracts, you still own the hardware. You can't simply turn off capacity; you're stuck with a stranded hardware investment.
Upgrade Complexity: Major updates might require planned downtime. Migration to newer hardware can be complex and disruptive.
Scalability Advantage: Cloud systems are significantly more scalable and flexible. They're designed for organisations where headcount and locations change frequently. On-premise systems work best for stable organisations with predictable headcount.
CRM Integration: Modern cloud phone systems integrate deeply with major CRM platforms (Salesforce, HubSpot, Pipedrive, Zoho). Integration typically means:
These integrations often work out-of-the-box or require simple configuration. Many providers offer pre-built integrations that work immediately.
Collaboration Tool Integration: Seamless integration with Microsoft Teams, Slack, Zoom, and other collaboration platforms. Phone features might appear directly in these applications.
Business Software Integration: Modern cloud systems typically offer APIs and webhooks for custom integration with business-specific applications. Custom integration is feasible without deep technical expertise.
Development Philosophy: Cloud systems are designed to be integration-friendly. They provide modern APIs, webhooks, and third-party marketplace integrations.
CRM Integration: Integration is possible but typically requires custom development. You might need to hire developers to build integration code, or the CRM vendor might charge for custom integration.
Collaboration Tool Integration: Integration is less seamless. You might need to manage multiple applications separately rather than having features unified.
Business Software Integration: Custom integration is possible but requires technical expertise. It's more complex and expensive than with cloud systems.
Development Philosophy: On-premise systems sometimes offer limited integration options. They're designed to be comprehensive standalone solutions rather than components of an integrated ecosystem.
Integration Advantage: Cloud systems integrate much more easily with modern business software. If integration is important (and for most modern organisations, it is), cloud systems are significantly better.
| Factor | Cloud System | On-Premise |
|---|---|---|
| Organization Size | 5-500+ users (especially 5-100) | 100-5,000+ users with stable headcount |
| Budget | Limited upfront capital | Significant upfront capital available |
| Technical Staff | No dedicated phone system expertise needed | 1-2 FTE dedicated IT staff |
| Headcount Stability | Changing headcount, distributed locations | Stable headcount, centralised location |
| Growth Plans | Expecting rapid growth | Stable or gradual growth |
| Feature Needs | Want modern, integrated features | Need specific legacy features |
| Compliance | Standard GDPR, HIPAA, PCI-DSS requirements | Complex, industry-specific compliance |
| Remote Work | Essential for operations | Minimal remote work needs |
| IT Infrastructure | Outsourced or limited IT | Strong in-house IT team |
| ROI Timeline | Quick ROI is important (under 2 years) | Long-term investment acceptable |
Small Businesses (5-50 employees): Cloud system almost always makes sense. You lack the IT expertise and budget for on-premise systems. The flexibility and low upfront cost of cloud systems are ideal for organisations that might grow, shrink, or change requirements.
Mid-Market Organisations (50-250 employees): Cloud systems are usually best. However, if you have dedicated IT staff, a stable headcount, and specific integration needs, on-premise systems might be worth evaluating.
Large Organisations (250+ employees): Both approaches are viable. Large organisations often have the IT expertise and capital to support on-premises systems. However, many large enterprises are moving to cloud systems because of the flexibility and reduced IT burden. Hybrid approaches might make sense if you need some on-premise functionality.
Organisations with Complex Compliance: If you're in healthcare, finance, or another heavily regulated industry, cloud systems often make more sense. Compliance requirements are built in, and compliance updates happen automatically.
Organisations with Distributed Teams: Cloud systems are essential. Supporting remote teams is far simpler with cloud infrastructure.
At T2K Voice & Data, we specialise in helping UK businesses find the perfect telecoms solution. Whether you're considering cloud VoIP, on-premise 3CX, or a hybrid approach, our experts can guide you to the right choice for your specific needs.
Compare Phone SystemsExplore essential features and capabilities of modern business phone systems.
In this guide, we explain everything you need to know about VoIP and more.
With the cost advantages, alongside greater flexibility and control, there's good reason why some businesses are turning their backs on fully managed cloud phone systems and opting for 3CX instead.
With over 25 years’ experience at T2k, Lee began his career as a telecoms engineer before progressing to Sales Director. He leverages his foundational technical knowledge to provide businesses with impartial, expert advice on modern communications, specialising in VoIP and cloud telephony. As a primary author for T2k, Lee is dedicated to demystifying complex technology for businesses of all sizes.
Your trusted technology partner.
